Fancy Nutella Milkshake

Nutella Milkshake That’s Extra-Fancy!

This delicious and super easy Nutella Milkshake (or Shaketini) is an absolutely delicious and attractive drink.

It’s an elevated Nutella Milkshake Mocktail that can be transformed into a cocktail as well. We have recipes for alcohol and non-alcohol drink versions, both equally delicious. The Boozy Nutella Shaketini uses Baileys Irish Cream while the Non-alcohol version is a fancy Nutella Milkshake Mocktail with a festive twist.

I can’t wait for you to try this recipe! It only needs a few ingredients and is so delicious. So, let’s get started!

Fancy Nutella Milkshake | Recipe

This recipe is going to make two serving sizes. We’re going to start off with a quarter cup of Nutella. So we’re going to get it all spooned out and get it into the blender.

Next up, two scoops of the ice cream of your choice. You can do vanilla for a traditional. We have a chocolate chip ice cream. So it’s basically vanilla and chocolate chips.

Next add two shots of milk. So it’s about 3oz of milk.

And now we blend. I’m using the Blendtec Total Blender Classic. I recently did a 10 year Review and tutorial of the Blendtec Blender, which you can click on here:

10 Year Review of Blendtec Total Blender Classic

I’ve owned it for a long time (over 10 years!) and I have a lot of insight on the product to share, including best practices on cleaning it, and numerous recipes you can make with this high powered blender. 

Back to the recipe! Blend all the ingredients in the Blendtec Blender until they are fully combined. It looks and smells so wonderful. I can’t wait to try this. But first, the presentation!

Fancy Nutella Milkshake | Presentation

So now all we have to do is make the glasses gorgeous.

Have two small dessert plates. Put Nutella on one plate and cane sugar on the other plate. Have two martini glasses ready to go.

First we’re going to flip one of our martini glasses upside down. Then carefully dip the rim of the martini glass into the Nutella on the plate. Then swirl the rim so that the Nutella fully lines the rim of the martini glass. Get it nicely on that rim.

Then move it over and dip the rim into the cane sugar by swirling again until the rim is fully coated in cane sugar on top of the Nutella. This is pure decadence. When you take your first sip, you will thank me.

Now repeat and doo the same for the second martini glass.

And finally, all we have left to do is pour in the Fancy Nutella Milkshakes into our fully rimmed martini glasses. The presentation is so gorgeous and looks so delicious. But how does it taste?

Fancy Nutella Milkshake | How Does It Taste?

Wow! These are so delicious. The Nutella and sugar rimmed martini glasses elevate this fancy Nutella Milkshake to make a next level drink that’s perfect for any celebration. It’s equally wonderful for a cozy night in! I hope you enjoy this recipe as much as I do.

Note: If you are making the version with alcohol, you will add 1-3oz of Baileys Irish Cream, depending on how strong you like your cocktail to taste. The other recipe adjustment is to only add 1.5oz of milk. You can choose the Baileys of your choice. I recommend Baileys Light, but you can do traditional Baileys as well. And they have a lot of fun flavors. There might be a really cool flavor that pairs really well with the Nutella. Enjoy, and please always drink responsibly.